First-Person Fiction Excerpt
By Laura Wright
Originally published in STRANGER STORIES (Black House Books, 2012).
This is it. My final entry before the obituary runs, assuming they bother printing one for a man like me. Maybe they’ll give me a full column: Bloodthirsty Killer Brought to Justice. That’s the story, right? The monster hiding in bedrooms. The psycho with a thing for powerful women.
I’m James Trondheim. Or, as the headlines christened me, the “Femme Fatale Killer.” Sounds cinematic. Dangerous. Sexy. Too bad I didn’t know I was playing the villain. If I had, maybe I would’ve leaned into the part. Given them a real show.
According to the prosecution, I “hate beautiful women in positions of power.” Can’t stand not being in control. So I kill them. That was their theory. No tangible evidence, no real motive, just speculation and a brand of vintage misogyny I thought had gone out in the 1970s. By the time they hauled me into court for one murder, they’d tied me to every unsolved female homicide in a five-state radius, stretching back for years. Like I was a one-man apocalypse.
I loved her. That’s what they never understood. Before politics. Before she became the smart, clean-cut political powerhouse. When she was just her.
But there’s more to it than that. I know there is. Something deeper, something no one’s talking about. Jennifer received a book through the mail. Old, leather-bound, reeking of dust and something else I couldn’t name. I saw it once. Just once. I think that’s all it needed.
I didn’t talk about the book at trial. Who would believe me? I was already the villain in their minds. Throw in talk of cursed pages or ancient powers, and I might as well confess to being a vampire while I’m at it. But considering my current predicament, maybe that would’ve drawn attention where it was needed.
So I sit here, quiet. Let them spin their story. Let the world believe I’m a predator who hunts by moonlight. My public defender, sorry, my public pretender, suggested a plea deal. Said the evidence looked bad. Said juries don’t like guys like me. Like I didn’t already know that.
I had no priors. No history. No reason. And still, the jury nodded along like they were hearing gospel. I guess it’s easier to swallow a tidy narrative than admit something worse might be at work. Something that doesn’t make sense in the daylight.
Now I’ve got an hour left. Then they’ll walk me down the hall, strap me in, and call it justice. Not “execution.” That’s too neat. Call it what it is: state-sanctioned murder. When the system kills an innocent man, it doesn’t magically become moral just because there’s paperwork.
I didn’t kill Jennifer. But I still think about her. That’s the worst part. I can’t get her out of my head. I dream about that mansion. That room. That goddamn book. Sometimes I think I hear her voice in the walls. In the rain. Tapping. Whispering. Like she’s still trying to warn me, or accuse me. I can’t tell anymore.
The inmates keep their distance. Always have. No beatdowns. No threats. Just eyes watching me, as though they can see something wrapped around me. One guy said I felt “thin,” like paper stretched too tight. He wouldn’t sit near me after that. I believe him. The rest of the inmate population treats me like I’m contagious. That’s fine. At least they leave me alone.
Sometimes I wonder about the thing that killed her. I know it’s still out there, smiling. Watching me rot in this cage. Maybe it’s already chosen its next name. Maybe it’s sitting in a courtroom somewhere, wearing a suit.
The governor’s got an hour, technically. But I know no one’s coming. Not for me. I’ve seen other men get last-minute calls. Miracles. I don’t get those. Never have.
I’m tired. Of explaining. Of breathing. Of being the villain in someone else’s fiction. Let them kill me. Maybe it ends the noise. Or maybe it just changes shape.
If anyone reads this, if it doesn’t get buried with me, know this:
I was innocent. My name is James Trondheim. And something else killed Jennifer Falin. Something no one wants to see. It’s still out there.
And that’s the truth.